Book Appointment

Why Choose Keystone Dentistry

Thoughtful Care. Trusted Experience. Dentistry That Puts You First.

Book Appointment
Voted Top Dentists (2010–2019)
30+ Years Serving Indianapolis
Same-Day Care for Busy Lives
Voted Top Dentists (2010–2019)
30+ Years Serving Indianapolis
Same-Day Care for Busy Lives
Our Philosophy

Care That Starts With Listening

0K+
Happy Smiles

For more than 30 years, Keystone Dentistry has proudly served Indianapolis and Carmel with care that feels personal, calm, and genuinely focused on people. We combine clinical expertise with meaningful relationships—because we believe great dentistry begins with trust.

Book Appointment
Our Values

A Thoughtful Approach to Dentistry

From the moment you arrive, you’re welcomed into a space designed to feel calm, positive, and reassuring. Our team greets you like family and helps you feel comfortable right away.
Book Appointment

Listening Comes First

We’re here to answer your questions and ensure you’re involved in the process during your visit. We won’t rush decisions.

Whole-Health View

We link oral health to your overall well-being, showing patients how their smile impacts their whole body health.

Better Care Learning

We use the latest tech and knowledge to make sure your care is all about experience and growth.

Feel the Experience

For more than 30 years, we've earned trust by being consistent, paying attention to the details, and staying committed to every patient.
Two men sitting and smiling indoors. The younger man has short dark hair and a beard, wearing a green sweater. The older man has short white hair, a beard, and glasses, wearing a dark zip-up sweater and jeans.
Total Wellness

Experience You Can Trust

With more than three decades of experience serving the local community, Keystone Dentistry has built a reputation for compassionate, comprehensive care. Our commitment to ongoing education ensures we stay current with the latest techniques and technology—so our patients benefit from both experience and innovation.

Dr. Kitcoff’s background includes:

Scientific Foundation
Bachelor’s degree in Biology with a minor in Chemistry – IUPUI

Clinical Training
Doctor of Dental Surgery – University of Tennessee Health Science Center

National Membership
Active member of the American Dental Association

Local Leadership
Member of the Indianapolis District Dental Society

A dental professional in a mask and gloves prepares to examine a reclining patient. The background features abstract beige and green shapes.
Beyond Dentistry

Comprehensive Care Under One Roof

Whether your needs are routine or complex, Keystone Dentistry offers a wide range of services in one convenient location. From preventive and family dentistry to cosmetic care, orthodontics, restorative treatments, and dental implants—we’re equipped to support your smile at every stage of life.

Our coordinated approach means fewer referrals, greater continuity, and care that feels seamless.

Our Integrity

What Sets Our Care Apart

A thoughtful, patient-centered approach that blends clinical expertise, clear communication, and comprehensive care designed to support long-term health and confidence.

Patient-First Care

At Keystone Dentistry, your needs come first—always. Every recommendation and every treatment is guided by comfort, trust, and what truly benefits your smile and overall well-being.

Advanced Care Made Clear

Our team is genuinely others-oriented. We offer only the care we would choose for our own families, ensuring a thoughtful, compassionate experience focused on comfort, respect, and lasting satisfaction.

Simplifying Complex Care

From advanced cosmetic treatments to IV sedation and dental implants, we use extensive training, ongoing education, and modern technology to make even complex dentistry clear, approachable, and predictable.

Complete Care, One Place

From routine checkups to same-day crowns and emergency care, we provide comprehensive services for every member of the family, all under one roof, delivered with efficiency and compassion.
Our Doctors

Experienced, Compassionate Care - Working Together

Our care is guided by a few simple principles that shape every experience. This philosophy allows us to deliver care that feels intentional, ethical, and deeply patient-focused.

Dr. Nicholas Kitcoff

Known for a comfort-first approach focused on improved health and confident smiles.
Meet Dr. Nicholas Kitcoff

Dr. Wayne Kinney

Brings a wellness-driven perspective, helping patients achieve long-term oral health and function.
Meet Dr. Wayne Kinney
Our Team

The Team Behind Your Care

What happens during your appointment

Thoughtful Presence
Care is never rushed. We take time to understand, explain, and respond—so each visit feels considered, not transactional.

Coordinated Support
Behind every appointment is a team working in sync, ensuring your experience is smooth, consistent, and centered on your comfort.

Meet Our Team
Patient Stories

What Our Patients Say

Every visit at Keystone Dentistry is shaped by the people we serve. These stories reflect real experiences shared by patients who value thoughtful care, clear communication, and a team that truly listens.
New Patients, Welcome

We’re Glad You’re Here

Whether it’s your first visit or you’re looking for a new dental home, we want getting started to feel simple and stress-free. Our team is here to guide you through every step and make your experience comfortable from day one.

Book Appointment

Simple Scheduling
Book appointments easily with a team that respects your time.

Flexible Payment Options
We accept dental insurance and offer financing options, including CareCredit.

Comfort-Focused Care
Every visit is designed to feel calm, unhurried, and supportive.

A Team That Listens
We take time to answer questions and make sure you feel understood.

Step Inside Keystone Dentistry

A Calm, Comfortable Space Designed Around You

Our office is designed to feel warm, welcoming, and unhurried—so you can feel at ease from the moment you arrive. Take a look around and see why patients say their experience here feels different.
Contact Us Today
Visit Our Office

Conveniently Located, Easy to Find

0K+
Happy Smiles
We do our best to offer appointment times that work for your day. When possible, we also provide same-day and emergency care during office hours. We proudly serve patients from Indianapolis, Carmel, and surrounding communities.
Office Hours
Mon, Tue, Wed: 8:00am – 5:00pm
Thu: 7:40am – 4:00pm
Total Wellness

Care That Goes Beyond Dentistry

At Keystone Dentistry, we look after more than just teeth. We care about how you feel, how confident you are, and how supported you feel at every visit. Our goal is to create an experience that’s thoughtful, reassuring, and built around you.
Book Appointment
Thoughtful Dental Guidance

Insights from Our Blog, Written to Support Your Care

Our blog shares clear, approachable guidance on dental care—so you can understand your options, feel confident in your decisions, and know what to expect before your visit.
Explore Our Blog

Get started

Name
Disclaimer