Book Appointment

Meet Dr. Nicholas Kitcoff, DDS

In Indianapolis, a dentist who loves his craft combines art and science to brighten his patients’ smiles. With cool techniques and the latest tech, he customizes treatments for everyone, turning dental visits into a positive experience and showing that dentistry can be both creative and precise.

Book Appointment
Voted Top Dentists (2010–2019)
30+ Years Serving Indianapolis
Same-Day Care for Busy Lives
Voted Top Dentists (2010–2019)
30+ Years Serving Indianapolis
Same-Day Care for Busy Lives
Care Approach

What Matters Most In His Care

0K+
Happy Smiles

Dr. Kitcoff believes dentistry should feel calm, clear, and personal. His care philosophy is rooted in building trust first by listening closely, explaining clearly, and never rushing decisions.

Patients often describe his approach as gentle and reassuring. He places strong emphasis on comfort, attention to detail, and creating an environment where patients feel at ease and respected. This relationship-first mindset shapes every experience at Keystone Dentistry.

  • Dawson Academy Trained
  • Division I Athlete
  • Indianapolis Native

The best part of my job is knowing I can dramatically change someone’s life by simply fixing their smile.

Treatment Approach

What You Can Expect With Dr. Kitcoff

Dental care that feels easy to understand and comfortable to experience. Centered on listening, trust, and care tailored to you.
Book Appointment

Modern, Gentle Dentistry

Dr. Kitcoff uses modern techniques and technology to deliver care that is comfortable, precise, and focused on long-term health.
A man in a blue shirt explains a document to a woman in a white top, both seated in a clinical setting, conveying a professional and informative tone.

Full Patient Involvement

Every patient is actively involved in their care. Dr. Kitcoff takes time to listen, explain each step clearly, and ensure decisions are made with confidence—without pressure or judgment.
A man with a beard and short hair, wearing a dark scrub top, sits smiling in a chair. He is in a room with large windows and lush green plants.

Tailor-Made Dental Care

Care is personalized for patients of all ages, with treatment plans thoughtfully designed to meet individual needs across preventive, cosmetic, orthodontic, and restorative dentistry.
Family plays a central role in my life, and it shapes the way I approach care—grounded, thoughtful, and focused on building long-term relationships.
Beyond Dentistry

The Person Behind the Practice

Outside of dentistry, Dr. Kitcoff enjoys spending time with his wife, Samantha, and their three daughters—Cora, Tessa, and Nellie. He values travel, staying active through basketball and golf, and remaining connected to his community.
Background & Experience

The Journey Behind the Care

Born and raised in Indianapolis, Dr. Kitcoff brings a strong connection to the community he serves—shaping care that feels familiar, personal, and grounded.

Academic Foundation

Dr. Kitcoff earned a Bachelor’s degree in Biology with a minor in Chemistry from Indiana University–Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI), building a strong scientific foundation for clinical care.

Advanced Training

He completed his DDS at the University of Tennessee and advanced his skills through a mini-residency at the Dawson Academy, reinforcing his commitment to precision and long-term outcomes.

Experience builds discipline

As a former Division I player, Dr. Kitcoff developed focus and a drive for improvement—qualities that shape his detail-driven approach to dentistry and belief in involving patients in decisions.

Care Guided by Purpose

During dental training, Dr. Kitcoff volunteered in Tennessee clinics, caring for underserved communities. This reinforced his patient-first philosophy: “Would I do it on me?”
Beyond Dentistry

Four Quick Questions, Answered Honestly.

1. What Do You Do Away from Dentistry?

I love to travel, especially to new countries and places I’ve never been before. I enjoy staying active by playing basketball and golf. But my most treasured moments are spent with my wife and three daughters, Cora, Tessa and Nellie. I love watching them grow.

2. What Was The Best Day of Your Life and Why?

Finding out that I am going to be a dad. Having children is one of the most rewarding things you can do, so finding out my wife was pregnant excited me to start this next chapter of my life.

3. Who Is Your Hero?

My parents. They have been amazing role models and set a great example for my brother and me. They have supported everything we’ve ever done, and I would not be in the position I’m in today without them.

4. What is an Interesting Fact About Yourself?

My family and I are avid travelers and have ventured to many places in the US, the Caribbean, Mexico, and Europe. Traveling to Greece is always important, and on our most recent trip, we stayed in a small town in northern Greece where my grandparents grew up.

Experienced, Compassionate Care - Working Together

Led by trusted dentists and supported by a compassionate team, Keystone Dentistry is a place where patients feel welcomed, listened to, and cared for.

Dr. Wayne Kinney

Brings a wellness-driven perspective, helping patients achieve long-term oral health and function.
Meet Dr. Wayne Kinney

Our Team

A team focused on clear communication and creating a calm, welcoming experience for patients.
Meet our Team
Patient Stories

What Our Patients Say

Every visit at Keystone Dentistry is shaped by the people we serve. These stories reflect real experiences shared by patients who value thoughtful care, clear communication, and a team that truly listens.
Visit Our Office

Conveniently Located, Easy to Find

0K+
Happy Smiles
We do our best to offer appointment times that work for your day. When possible, we also provide same-day and emergency care during office hours. We proudly serve patients from Indianapolis, Carmel, and surrounding communities.
Office Hours
Mon, Tue, Wed: 8:00am – 5:00pm
Thu: 7:40am – 4:00pm
Total Wellness

Care That Goes Beyond Dentistry

At Keystone Dentistry, we look after more than just teeth. We care about how you feel, how confident you are, and how supported you feel at every visit. Our goal is to create an experience that’s thoughtful, reassuring, and built around you.
Book Appointment

Get started

Name
Disclaimer